Jacks 3-2-1 feeding schedule- issue when I flip into flower

So I have noticed before I flip to flower this 3-2-1 works great. The TDS doesn’t really increase in my res. They will grow endlesssly without issue I believe ( I have some over 4 months in veg) using 3-2-1.

Within 2 weeks of flipping the lights, I get cal-mag def and leaves start to wither and fall ( albeit the lower/hidden leaves). It’s only after I flip to flower does this happen.

The res also had to be changed out every fill up, or else the TDS shoots up. I am assuming the plant isn’t consuming something, likely nitrogen, during flower.

Any suggestions with minimal costs to increase the Cal-mag and remove the nutes it doesn’t need during flower, or should I just suplement the cal-mag and change the res weekly?

Seems to me I might be better off changing up the feed instead of following one and done through the whole grow.

2 Likes




Assuming this is indeed cal/mag def symptoms.

2 Likes

Jacks has a modified schedule for flower. 321 gets adjusted to raise the P & K values while reducing the N. Also if your growing under led’s you should be using CalMag throughout your grow imo

7 Likes

Thanks. I’ll have to look into that. I do usually use cal-mag, I had ran out and didn’t see any deficiencies until flower.

I’ll check it out and adjust the 3-2-1 schedule.

5 Likes

Happy cake day!

2 Likes

You can simply run the Jacks at 4-2 and that will drop nitrogen and raise the P and K. Lots of folks here use that.

5 Likes

Thanks. So it’s a literal 4G Part A and 2G cal-nit per gallon?

I currently use this:

3.6g of Part A
2.4g of Part B
1.5g of Epsom salt

2 Likes

Flower with Jacks is 3.8, 2.2, 1.2 or sub out the epsom salts for CalMag if you go a different route

4 Likes

It’s close to what I currently use.

You don’t think 0.2 per gallon would make that big of a difference do you?

2 Likes

Well to be honest I mix up 4 gallons of jacks nutes into 5 gal of water.


I use to push the thresholds but my plants react much better with a tad less than recommended amounts.

11 Likes

See, those look fine.

I’m betting it’s just a cal-mag deficiency due to my water or
Something.

4 Likes

What is your res ph value when you feed? Does it drift over a period of time?

5 Likes

It stays relatively the same, I run it at 5.7-5.8. Most of the time I put 5.9 in it and it drops a smidgen.

Once switched to flower for a couple weeks, I have to drain and clean before filling up each time, otherwise the TDS goes insanely high and the PH tries to go low.

5 Likes

Jumping in because of the use of cal-mag deficiency in a singular tense. Calcium in 321 recipe is mainly provided from calcium nitrate (part b) and magnesium is provided from magnesium sulfate (epsom salt). Since calcium deficiency and magnesium deficiency are two different issues, you need to determine which you have in order to address the issue properly. See below for common deficiencies in cannabis.

Additionally, not every issue with a plant is a nutrient deficiency. Sometimes certain elements will become locked out from ph or inappropriate levels of certain elements. Or a larger than normal demand for specific elements due to environmental conditions or excessive levels of other elements. See mulders chart below

Your plants don’t display typical symptom of a calcium or magnesium deficiency. They do however appear to show signs of nitrogen toxicity. Now your ph looks good but crashes and ec shoots up. It sounds like your plants taking water but leaving nutrients. How big is your res? And how much is water dropping at what frequency are you filling or changing? How quickly from reset do you see ph crash and ec rise?

One thing I have experienced this with significantly out of range vapor pressure deficit. But could be anything.

8 Likes

Thank you. I thought nitrogen toxicity was dark green which I am not experiencing.

You bring up several good points. Right now they are in a conditioned space. Tent stays under 79F and warmer than 68F. Typically 77F. Humidity however, ranges around 45%, give or take 10% given the cycle.

It does sound like that to me too, I thought it would be because I am adding to
Much X during flower, which it doesn’t need. I didn’t really consider it could just be drinking more water than nutrients, especially if the RH drops. What’s a good level of RH for flower?

It’s very small, 5 gallons. It drinks about 5 gallons every week.

During veg, all goes well. Only after flip. So say that 5 gallons went in and stayed at 1000PPM and a good PH. When I check it again it’s fine, when I add the missing 2 gallons, it’s a little high on the ppm but fine still. By the 2nd “fill” the PPM will be too high and the PH too low.

4 Likes

Oh, sorry. Yeah it doesn’t quite look like any of those deficiencies.

4 Likes

It is for me, 4g a, 2 g b, and I still use Epsom at 1.5 g, my lights love the extra mag.

4 Likes

Me too, it lands my EC about perfectly.

6 Likes

No apologies needed, just trying to take a systematic approach to helping you track this down.

I thought nitrogen looked a little high from this pic. Looks dark, waxy, and clawed/burnt tips.

You shouldn’t be seeing any major issues at 79⁰ and 45% rh either.

Have you been checking ph and ec/tds before topping off? Like after one day of a fresh res I’m curious what these look like. You could just be dealing with inconsistencies due to uptake and having the small res. If you lose 20% of your water in one day it could be having inverse effect on your ec which could in turn cause swings in your ph. In a hydroponic system it doesn’t take much for ph to cause problems. It’s usually pretty good between 5.5 and 6.0, outside of that things can get shitty quickly.

4 Likes

Those appear to be older fan leaves that begin to die once in flower. I see no signs of C def. Plants will not necessarily look any better as the plants don’t produce leaves in flower.

I use a modified schedule right at the flip. 2-2-2-1.2 with the last ingredient MKP: monopotassium phosphate. Then resume 3-2-1.

If you aren’t running silica, you should.

Normally my harvested plants are still green and vibrant.

4 Likes