What do you guys think? Too much water?
They look good to me
They need more room and then a good watering after transplant
Think they are ready for the 5 gallon buckets?
. Not sure how well you can see it but you can actually see the roots through the bucket
Get them babies out of those tiny trays and into their final home 
Working on that this morning!
Your in NY you should look to see if you have a Agway near you they are carrying a lot of weed friendly soils and nutes that being said never had a problem with seedlings and OF