Preparing for Ohio Legalization, narrowed down to Cmh, or Qb roughly 3x3 to 4x4 grow space

Haha killing me… You guys are a blast. Thanks for not getting too frustrated w me. I just see everyone starting out small then wanting more room. My budget will be 400.00 to start.

You won’t be very happy with just one in a 5x5 space. If you go that route, shrink down area you’re going to use to around 2x4 space.

Three of 260 kits should get you to at least a ppfd average of about 700 umols per second. Probably a little higher with some bonus current from drivers. That’s about perfect light intensity levels for a really efficient grow.

but… 3x 320w Qb’s would rock a 5x5.!!

Would be over light saturation levels without supplementing co2. I’m not against people wanting to go through with that. But it’s also not ideal for someone wanting to hold a budget.

idk for sure, but seems like, with enough height, 900 watts of QB would be ideal…???
960 watts in a 5x5 is only 38 watts per square foot,
i m running ~43 wpsf in flower, but there is 3/16 inch glass between the lights/plants.
and… i like a lot of light, tried ‘efficient’ lighting and moved up.!!

43 wpsf seems absurd to me, i’d use no lower then 60 wpsf of HID.!
i’d use no less then 100 wpsf of floro for flower now.! LOL

Done… This is the plan x-1 260 now and will go from their…

I thought we were over the whole watts per square foot thing? Every time there’s an upgrade in efficacy the par per watt goes up, therefore required power levels go down. It basically renders any ratio of power consumption useless. 38 watts per square foot may be crap with a mass produced blurple panel, fluorescent, or some hid lights. But you get into a fixture that has double the flux per watt and you can be cooking with steam very quickly.

Hlg’s third party test report has 301b 288’s board level efficacy running 2.63 umol/joule minimum at 2100ma. At 102+ watts per board that’s a total flux of 270 umols per second per board. The way meanwell nameplates are, I bet it’s closer to 280-290 umols per second per board.

The latest DLI data on cannabis suggests diminishing returns after ppfd averages between 600-800 umols per second. The three 260 kits puts one right in the wheelhouse. Light intensity beyond that requires some pretty heavy spending to justify, and probably a fairly experienced grower to get the most of. A total flux of 1600 umols/s is pushing anything fluence or gavita have to offer, and those are professional grade lights designed for commercial operation.

sorry dbrn, but i do not own a quantum meter.!
even a quantum meter has its limitations tho,
it only measures visible light (400-700nm),
its close but does not include all of the PAR.

for those who do own a quantum meter…
from the little research i’ve done and videos watched,
i think flowering cannabis does best around 800 ppfd,
over 1000 and u need Co2 to benefit from the extra light,
to me 600 ppfd in flower is a little low.

now the question is…
what r the ppfd measurements across a 5x5 area with 3x 260w and 3x 320w QB’s.?
able to be hung higher, will the 320’s provide better ppfd (600+) around the edges.?

personally, in a 5x5, i’d do a 9 board DIY build and get maximum coverage.!
i’d shoot for around 900 watts and use my candle power light meter to even out the coverage.

You don’t need a quantum sensor to measure flux over area.

9 boards at 2100ma should have a total flux around 2400 umols per second, a 5x5 is 25 ft² is about 2.32m². Ppfd average of about 1040-1050 umols per second. Well above even your target of 800 umols/s.

Light saturation levels are indeed around 1000 umols/s on ambient co2. But diminishing returns are shown at 800 umols/s, sometimes less depending on conditions. Moving the light higher doesn’t change the amount of light in the space either. There is certainly points where better coverage is had, but that has just an much to do with led spacing in respect to height. If you move light too high it becomes eaten up by walls. In my opinion, it’s very difficult to justify buying more light to then waste it running at improper height.

I would maybe be on board with you if we were looking at sealed room with controlled co2 supplementation. This scenario is certainly not there, so I don’t really see any reason to go that big even if budget wasn’t an issue. All the more reason since cost is an uphill battle. Three 260 kits makes the most sense. To me even if I wanted more light later it’s a very easy setup to add a couple of 660nm strips make 800 umol/s ppfd average.

how would that compare to 9x 65w, 100w, or 135w QB kits.?
i guess what i m asking is… what is the average ppfd for each of those.?

this chart shows the 800 ppfd sweet spot…

i know this is a single bulb fixture, but u can see how the PAR levels actually increase slightly around the perimeter when the fixture is raised 6"…

this is the HLG 550…

@Thumper If your following the discussion above the 260W XL footprint is:

Formula is power x ppf per watt per second = total flux.

Total flux/area in m² = ppfd average.

Yup. But doesn’t mean it would continue to happen if raised another 6". Maybe it would, but at some point more light would hit the walls and not 100% of it would be reflected. Do you think it’s a coincidence that the checkmark on the chart is almost exactly where the ppfd average of the 260 kits would be? It’s not, probably based on the same studies I use to layout light designs.

Indeed… Thank you

@WickedAle,
thank u sir, i could not find that chart last night to save my life.!

@dbrn32, sorry to keep bothering u, but…
this is the reason i think quantum meter measurements r worth WAY more then calculated averages.!
in Ale’s chart disregard the bottom and top 2 rows of circles, that would leave a 2x4 area,
it shows the 1000 ppfd under each board, but `the ppfd drops below flowering levels at the 4’ mark,
i know, reflective walls would help, but what r those numbers gonna be at 5’.?
usable flower light still.?
this is the reason i suggested the triple 320’s, in hopes there’d be enough light around the walls in a 5x5, my theory is…
more power = more ppfd = light higher = more light reaching walls…???

again, i don’t think any HLG fixture fits 5x5 tents, i’d go with DIY QB’s.!!

Well it’s not a bad theory. But again you can adjust that with your spacing. Running an additional board in the middle is going to create higher intensity of middle, which would be more light, but create higher drop off near edges. So it doesn’t really solve the issue you’re suggesting. Running more balanced par levels is more beneficial, but you’re not going to see a major difference in a grow that measures 1000 umols in the center and 500 umols at the edge. Especially referencing a model taken in open air. I could summon multiple members that I’ve helped layout lights that will tell you they get as big or bigger buds on sides and corners of their tents as they do in the middle. One of them running a single point light source at considerably less than 30 watts per square foot.

so…
u r saying neither the 320w or 260w QB is suited for a 5x5…???
both r 3’ long, no way to space them to the 5’ width.

sounds like with a 5x5 tent we’d have to go DIY…???

this is an interesting test of the 90w, 135w, and the 260w (regular)…
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KbzTkz4gKzg
according to these tests, the reg. 260 would do good in a 3x3.

You guys are awesome! I am going to keep saving a minute as I have time here in Ohio… Got some side work lined :point_up: I don’t use work money too much for new hobbies etc. I may order the first board and build my frame I love to tinker by nature, want a little diy anyhow and it will make time go by. It could be Nov before I can grow here or later… But man am I enjoying my time here. So please continue… Is it hard to R&R diodes, or even possible to repair? Thanks for everything! Thump…

listen to dbrn on lighting.!!
take what i have to say with doubt…
i have a big mouth, small brain and a chit ton of theories.! LOL

If I was more educated I would love to join in the debate… But as I am not I am learning allot and how to look at things from both perspectives. My girl brought home bush beans, a lemon tree, cantalope etc… Said baby put that tent up and lets grow veggies & etc for awhile, so… Maybe a simple lil t5 and some veggies for a few while building my board.

That’s not what I said. I said if balanced intensity was what you’re looking for, 3 more boards in the center of the other 6 doesn’t solve the issue. Could just as likely make it worse.

I’m not necessarily arguing that a DIY project isn’t a better option. Just that three qb 320 kits isn’t the best choice for this grower.